Western Astrology is not true. Vedic/ Sidereal astrology is correct. ((IMPORTANT VIDEO))

[ImprisonedSoul]

This video right here explains why Western/ Tropical is wrong in a very straight forward manner. Actual science/ astronomy does **NOT** support Western/ Tropical astrology.

[ImprisonedSoul]

13 constellations exist; NOT 12... And the Vedic/ Sidereal system supports all 13 constellations.

ACTUAL Scientific source: https://www.livescience.com/4667-astrological-sign.html
Astrology: Why Your Zodiac Sign and Horoscope Are Wrong

https://trusted-astrology.com/sidereal- ... 20a%20baby.

[ImprisonedSoul]

Sidereal Birth Chart Calculator here: https://cafeastrology.com/free-natal-ch ... vedic.html

[AnonPoster]

There was a time when I thought astrology per general is bullshit.

As for vedic I am not curious but I don't know anything about it so I have no opinion.

Western astrology is REAL. In case you don't understand it is because you don't like what you see about yourself and muah you move to vedic because it might sound better and everybody wants to feel better about themseves isn't it.

I spent years looking at close people's chart and I am still humble in my understanding but everything to the last bit it's real.

However it's up to people and their experience to decide for whatever.

[ImprisonedSoul]

There was a time when I thought astrology per general is bullshit.

As for vedic I am not curious but I don't know anything about it so I have no opinion.

Western astrology is REAL. In case you don't understand it is because you don't like what you see about yourself and muah you move to vedic because it might sound better and everybody wants to feel better about themseves isn't it.

I spent years looking at close people's chart and I am still humble in my understanding but everything to the last bit it's real.

However it's up to people and their experience to decide for whatever.

Lol; sure... What ever you say. Smith. https://tse1.mm.bing.net/th?id=OIP.cNa4 ... =202&h=162

And you do realize that I have that little thing called; "Proof"... Right? Astronomy > Your bullshit

[AnonPoster]

The vedic system is great to use and may be quite useful but the chart must be calculated using the western system. The reason for this is vedic charts are not accurate when dealing with the houses and often signs of planets. You will likely have the wrong ascendant and house placements and maybe even several planets in the wrong signs and houses as well as aspects that are not there in the western system when dealing with stuff like the ascendant or midheaven (of course likely in the wrong sign too the ascendant is quite a bad thing to mess up on in a chart on its own as this will give you the wrong ruling planet likely also in the wrong sign)

If you use the vedic calculation of the chart there will be a lot of stuff that doesn't make sense.

An example in Vedic Astrology my sun is Sagittarius which doesn't make sense considering I am deep and sensitive somewhat moody and revengeful more like a Scorpio.

My Mercury is in Scorpio in the vedic chart. I am talkative and social quite a lot of time kind of detached in thinking doesn't make sense I fit more Libra.

My Jupiter is in Pisces in Vedic astrology. This doesn't make sense I consider myself a spiritual warrior and can be pushy and impatient in dealing with beliefs. I have a lot of confidence like Jupiter in Aries.

So those are three things I know are wrong in my own chart. Just about everything is changed in the vedic calculation.

Yeah I know some of it can make sense in some cases due to other placements but why use a system that is wrong.


Also if someone is using the vedic calculation to start a working with a planet they risk in some cases even starting it with the planet in fall or detriment if the exalted or home sign is next to a sign of fall or detriment with the planet.

I also am an experienced reader of energy I will tell you the western system is very close to what energies are actually going on within about 30 seconds of a degree. The vedic system is so far off what is actually going on it doesn't make sense.

If you want to test this go ahead do so say the planitary mantra of something or tune into the planet right near when it changes signs. You will see. I have tested this out.

I think it's important people use a system that is actually accurate. Now all the info and stuff in vedic astrology is great I love it when using western calculations you can gain a lot of insight into stuff. So no critique of the system itself just this. An entire system fails though when it has something important in it that is not accurate. This is why it doesn't make sense to a lot of people.

Also there is no 13th constellation that is nonsense.

[ImprisonedSoul]

The vedic system is great to use and may be quite useful but the chart must be calculated using the western system. The reason for this is vedic charts are not accurate when dealing with the houses and often signs of planets. You will likely have the wrong ascendant and house placements and maybe even several planets in the wrong signs and houses as well as aspects that are not there in the western system when dealing with stuff like the ascendant or midheaven (of course likely in the wrong sign too the ascendant is quite a bad thing to mess up on in a chart on its own as this will give you the wrong ruling planet likely also in the wrong sign)

If you use the vedic calculation of the chart there will be a lot of stuff that doesn't make sense.

Also if someone is using the vedic calculation to start a working with a planet they risk in some cases even starting it with the planet in fall or detriment if the exalted or home sign is next to a sign of fall or detriment with the planet.

I also am an experienced reader of energy I will tell you the western system is very close to what energies are actually going on within about 30 seconds of a degree. The vedic system is so far off what is actually going on it doesn't make sense.

If you want to test this go ahead do so say the planitary mantra of something or tune into the planet right near when it changes signs. You will see. I have tested this out.

I think it's important people use a system that is actually accurate. Now all the info and stuff in vedic astrology is great I love it when using western calculations you can gain a lot of insight into stuff. So no critique of the system itself just this. An entire system fails though when it has something important in it that is not accurate. This is why it doesn't make sense to a lot of people.

Also there is no 13th constellation that is nonsense.

I highly doubt that a lot of what you said is even truthful; knowing how Vedic is a much older form of astrology than Western is, and knowing how many other mainstream astrologers ((that do take astrology serious; and have for decades and decades of their lives)) would say that Vedic is ultimately better as well ((and would also disagree with you)); when it comes to personalities and predicting future events...

And also knowing how Western is not an astronomically correct form of astrology either ((as I *proved* up above with the livescience link)).

On top of that note; my Vedic chart fits my personality perfectly. =)

[AnonPoster]

The vedic system is great to use and may be quite useful but the chart must be calculated using the western system. The reason for this is vedic charts are not accurate when dealing with the houses and often signs of planets. You will likely have the wrong ascendant and house placements and maybe even several planets in the wrong signs and houses as well as aspects that are not there in the western system when dealing with stuff like the ascendant or midheaven (of course likely in the wrong sign too the ascendant is quite a bad thing to mess up on in a chart on its own as this will give you the wrong ruling planet likely also in the wrong sign)

If you use the vedic calculation of the chart there will be a lot of stuff that doesn't make sense.

Also if someone is using the vedic calculation to start a working with a planet they risk in some cases even starting it with the planet in fall or detriment if the exalted or home sign is next to a sign of fall or detriment with the planet.

I also am an experienced reader of energy I will tell you the western system is very close to what energies are actually going on within about 30 seconds of a degree. The vedic system is so far off what is actually going on it doesn't make sense.

If you want to test this go ahead do so say the planitary mantra of something or tune into the planet right near when it changes signs. You will see. I have tested this out.

I think it's important people use a system that is actually accurate. Now all the info and stuff in vedic astrology is great I love it when using western calculations you can gain a lot of insight into stuff. So no critique of the system itself just this. An entire system fails though when it has something important in it that is not accurate. This is why it doesn't make sense to a lot of people.

Also there is no 13th constellation that is nonsense.

I highly doubt that a lot of what you said is even truthful; knowing how Vedic is a much older form of astrology than Western is... And also knowing how Western is not an astronomically correct form of astrology.

On top of that note; my Vedic chart fits my personality perfectly. =)

I am telling the truth. I do not believe vedic astrology is accurate I edited the above to give about 3 examples. The signs are wrong as are house placements. This pretty much invalidates the entire system.

You go ahead use this. Dont come crying to me about the fact most your workings are really weak cause you started them at a time that is not relevent to them or even a negative time to start them if you use planet positions to start workings. Also I am guessing the vedic astrologers know this is bunk so far as the calculations so they edit meanings of signs and aspects and houses to try and fool unsuspecting people into thinking it makes sense and fits them.

[AnonPoster]

The vedic system is great to use and may be quite useful but the chart must be calculated using the western system. The reason for this is vedic charts are not accurate when dealing with the houses and often signs of planets. You will likely have the wrong ascendant and house placements and maybe even several planets in the wrong signs and houses as well as aspects that are not there in the western system when dealing with stuff like the ascendant or midheaven (of course likely in the wrong sign too the ascendant is quite a bad thing to mess up on in a chart on its own as this will give you the wrong ruling planet likely also in the wrong sign)

If you use the vedic calculation of the chart there will be a lot of stuff that doesn't make sense.

Also if someone is using the vedic calculation to start a working with a planet they risk in some cases even starting it with the planet in fall or detriment if the exalted or home sign is next to a sign of fall or detriment with the planet.

I also am an experienced reader of energy I will tell you the western system is very close to what energies are actually going on within about 30 seconds of a degree. The vedic system is so far off what is actually going on it doesn't make sense.

If you want to test this go ahead do so say the planitary mantra of something or tune into the planet right near when it changes signs. You will see. I have tested this out.

I think it's important people use a system that is actually accurate. Now all the info and stuff in vedic astrology is great I love it when using western calculations you can gain a lot of insight into stuff. So no critique of the system itself just this. An entire system fails though when it has something important in it that is not accurate. This is why it doesn't make sense to a lot of people.

Also there is no 13th constellation that is nonsense.

I highly doubt that a lot of what you said is even truthful; knowing how Vedic is a much older form of astrology than Western is, and knowing how many other mainstream astrologers ((that do take astrology serious; and have for decades and decades of their lives)) would say that Vedic is ultimately better as well ((and would also disagree with you)); when it comes to personalities and predicting future events...

And also knowing how Western is not an astronomically correct form of astrology either ((as I *proved* up above with the livescience link)).

On top of that note; my Vedic chart fits my personality perfectly. =)

The western astrology system is more close to the origional the Jews corrupted nearly all of Hinduism and turned it into a weak watered down Christianity 2.0 kind of thing. Go ahead use corruptions at your own risk and waste years of time not getting very far with stuff.

[ImprisonedSoul]

The vedic system is great to use and may be quite useful but the chart must be calculated using the western system. The reason for this is vedic charts are not accurate when dealing with the houses and often signs of planets. You will likely have the wrong ascendant and house placements and maybe even several planets in the wrong signs and houses as well as aspects that are not there in the western system when dealing with stuff like the ascendant or midheaven (of course likely in the wrong sign too the ascendant is quite a bad thing to mess up on in a chart on its own as this will give you the wrong ruling planet likely also in the wrong sign)

If you use the vedic calculation of the chart there will be a lot of stuff that doesn't make sense.

Also if someone is using the vedic calculation to start a working with a planet they risk in some cases even starting it with the planet in fall or detriment if the exalted or home sign is next to a sign of fall or detriment with the planet.

I also am an experienced reader of energy I will tell you the western system is very close to what energies are actually going on within about 30 seconds of a degree. The vedic system is so far off what is actually going on it doesn't make sense.

If you want to test this go ahead do so say the planitary mantra of something or tune into the planet right near when it changes signs. You will see. I have tested this out.

I think it's important people use a system that is actually accurate. Now all the info and stuff in vedic astrology is great I love it when using western calculations you can gain a lot of insight into stuff. So no critique of the system itself just this. An entire system fails though when it has something important in it that is not accurate. This is why it doesn't make sense to a lot of people.

Also there is no 13th constellation that is nonsense.

I highly doubt that a lot of what you said is even truthful; knowing how Vedic is a much older form of astrology than Western is... And also knowing how Western is not an astronomically correct form of astrology.

On top of that note; my Vedic chart fits my personality perfectly. =)

I am telling the truth. I do not believe vedic astrology is accurate I edited the above to give about 3 examples. The signs are wrong as are house placements. This pretty much invalidates the entire system.

You go ahead use this. I am guessing the vedic astrologers know this is bunk so far as the calculations so they edit meanings of signs and aspects and houses to try and fool unsuspecting people into thinking it makes sense and fits them.

What ever you say. I'm just hoping people would take the word of actual scientists; over someone like yourself. You're a very dishonest... And you're big on promoting BS in many forms.

And there is a 13th constellation... This is an established scientific fact: https://www.inverse.com/article/21365-s ... uchus-nasa HERE'S THE SCIENCE BEHIND OPHIUCHUS, THE ZODIAC'S NEW CONSTELLATION

https://nypost.com/2020/07/17/nasa-says ... ophiuchus/ NASA has been forced to announce that it didn’t create a 13th zodiac sign, the sign has always existed.

https://sciencebriefss.com/algebra/is-o ... 13th-sign/ Is Ophiuchus the 13th Sign?

You can find link after link, after link from scientific sources ((on Google)) saying that Ophiuchus **IS** an actual constellation; and the 13th constellation. This corresponds with Vedic astrology, because Vedic actually goes by 13 sun signs; not 12, and they've always had it that way too ((for thousands and thousands of years)). Vedic astrology is the oldest form of astrology; known to man.